This is where I would be throwing in some fantastically witty banter about Canada, but I bet you’re feeling like that shit is kinda tired. I’m sure thinking that right now. Plus, I have nothing. No jokes. I just have to call it like I see it. With the Parades, the Fires, the Eyes, the Pornographers, the “Nicer America” is getting more exposure than a blooper reel on Taradise (cue drums).
Montreal, blah blah blah. What about about Toronto? The home of the Hockey Hall of Fame is the stomping ground for the gigantic collective Broken Social Scene, of which many successful off shoots and associates (Stars to name one) have branched out. Of them all, Metric might be the most dynamic.
Once again, I find myself in position to gush. Emily Haines is a bombshell. Haines’ range of voice, the pulsing synths, the disco drive and one of the most incredible live shows in the circuit makes them a handsome draw.
If Old World Underground, Where Are You Now? put them on the map, Live It Out, their new release, attempts the building process, but not without its snags and minor disasters. Live It Out is not as solid top to bottom as its predecessor, but with a few outstanding offerings makes it well worth the slight disappointment.
The album opens with "Empty" which over-dramatically switches from its hushed whisper intro to an all out guitar assualt with no time to brace yourself. The sonic burst of "Empty" sets the tone for Live It Out, an album of adequate melodies, guatir rockers and simple arrangements, a collection of "nothing specials". The next track, "Glass Ceiling" offers no savior, as the melody line is even more drab than the track before, sort of pounding away with no emotion. It's not sexy.
The main issue the Metric-faithful will have is that the album is simply not dancy. For those who didn't care for Haines razor sharp commentaries on the war in Iraq or her war against the scene, took comfort in the riding hi-hats and thumping kick. Asses were shaking and there was not a head turned when Haines slyly made fun of every white belted haircut in the place (me included). Live It Out sorely needs a few of those tracks, and "Poster of Girl" is not quite enough, though its synth hooks and disco beat valiantly tries to pick up the slack.
However, with a handful of mediocre, barely passable cuts, Metric also brings it on a handful of keepers. Live It Out is as close as it comes to modern day "alt-rock" album. They walk a fine line between respectable synth-punk and mid 90s radio cheese, but I've never heard a Republica song as brillaint as "Patriarch on a Vespa" or "Handshakes". "Patriarch on a Vespa" is a tailor made live song, arrangement-wise nothing spectacular but gets driven by Haines' maniacal, stuttering vocal outbursts. "Handshakes" is powered by guitarist Jimmy Shaw in what might be the guitar pop song of the year if it didn't tail off into a Haines rant, as snappy as it is ("Buy this car to drive to work/Drive to work to pay for this car"). "Moster Hospital" is also a fantastic single with bouncy drum work, anthemic chorus and tons of sass. The obligatory ballad-y tracks fare decently well. "Ending Start" and "Police and the Private" aren't gonna make you cry but they might make you play air piano. Or is that just me?
While Metric seemingly got impossibly more simple, their cousins in Broken Social Scene tried the opposite, making a bigger more complex album than their breakthrough You Forgot It In People. The lineup is bigger, arrangements are more detailed, and gridwork more vast. This makes for some tangled wires and short circuits, but again these damn Canucks are pretty damn resilient.
You Forgot It In People was an exercise in control. Here is band that can do a lot. They made an album both experimental and personal. And they not only succeeded, they may have set the bar insanely high. Broken Social Scene loses a lot of the intimacy because of its vast nature and sort of mad scientist style meandering. Old tracks like "Stars and Sons", "Almost Crimes" and "Lover's Spit" had a sense of containment, as if they bottled up something magical in a 5 minute song. Many of the tracks on Broken Social Scene feel like the genie was let out of the lamp.
This isn't as dire as it may sound. They album is still enjoyable to the max, but again the expectations are great, and I naively hoped they would out-do themselves. Explosive tracks like "Superconnected" and "Fire Eye'd Boy" still crank it up with no pretention; they are unfuckwithable. Haines-led ballad "Swimmers" defintiely hold a candle to "Anthems For Seventeen Year Old Girl" with its gentle sea-water like flow and breezy melody. And Kevin Drew describes "It's All Gonna Break" as "Bob Seger on acid" which is more accurate than playing Duck Hunt two feet away from the TV. Evidently, Bob Seger on acid kind of sounds like Nada Surf.
Their expansive sound has lent to excellent a jazzy vibe (again thanks in part to the multi-talented Jimmy Shaw, trumpet player) in songs like opener "Our Faces Split the Coast in Half" and "Hotel". Horns accent the ending sequence of possibly the top track of the album "7/4 (Shoreline)", led by my heroine Leslie Feist, whose voice has never been so recognizable, confident and goddamn desireable. Of course, I've always believed Feist was amazing.
Burdened by high expectations, both Live It Out and Broken Social Scene inevitably disappoint, but I'd like to think of it as getting a point for tie (in hockey, of course, though come to think about it, I think they changed all those rules with the new agreement and stuff). You didn't win but you should be rewarded for not losing.
Blogger's Note: I sound like hard man here, but I do adore both records.
Metric is playing Slim's with Death of the Party supporting 11/3/05. Broken Social Scene rocks The Grand with the fabulous and gorgeous Feist supporting 11/9/05.
Metric: http://www.ilovemetric.com
Broken Social Scene: http://www.arts-crafts.ca/bss